I started with a list of 10, and narrowed it down to 7 by removing:
Mielikki: Goddess of forests, forest creatures, rangers, dryads, autumn. Neutral Good.
Tymora: Goddess of good fortune, skill, victory, adventurers. Chaotic Good.
Tyr: God of justice. Lawful Good.
I felt that Silvanus and Mielikki overlapped a bit, as did Torm and Tyr. I removed Tymora because if you have good fortune after worshiping a Goddess of luck, then it's not luck anymore.
I left out the Evil Gods on purpose. If you want one, I would remove Torm and replace him with one of the following:
Bane: God of hatred, fear, and tyranny. Lawful Evil.
Cyric: God of murder, lies, intrigue, strife, deception, illusion. Chaotic Evil.
Mask: God of thieves, thievery, shadows. Neutral Evil.
I would probably choose Mask, because Bane and Cyric seem novel-specific to me and Bane may or may not be dead.